Broadcom Dismissal Order

Here is Judge Cormac Carney’s Dismissal Order in U.S. v. William J. Ruehle and U.S. v. Henry T. Nicholas. Most of the newspaper stories on the Broadcom debacle failed to note that Judge Carney dimissed the case against Ruehle for insufficiency of the evidence as well as prosecutorial misconduct. Ruehle’s Rule 29 Motion was granted after jeopardy attached, but before the jury began deliberating. Therefore, the government cannot appeal, and Ruehle cannot be re-tried. With respect to Nicholas, he wasn’t even on trial yet at the time of Carney’s order dismissing the Indictment with prejudice. The government can therefore appeal the dismissal in Nicholas’s case.